- 
  
  
 - 
  
  
 - 
  
  Moses Fleetwood Walker, Catcher for Toledo, Louisville
 - 
  
  
 - 
  
  James Peters, for the Somerset County Team
 - 
  
  Charles Follis, for the Shelby Steamfitters
 - 
  
  Joe Johnson, for Fitzroy
 - 
  
  
 - 
  
  
 - 
  
  Fritz Pollard, Akron Pros. While coaching Fritz was still playing for his team.
 - 
  
  
 - 
  
  Wataru Misaka, Point Guard for the New York Knicks
 - 
  
  Jackie Robinson, Northern League, Second Baseman for the Brooklyn Dodgers
 - 
  
  Theodore Cecil Thompson, for the English National Team
 - 
  
  Don Barksdale
 - 
  
  William Felton Russel, Center for the Boston Celtics. He then proceeded to win the award 4 more times in the 1960 – 61, 1961 – 62, 1962 – 63 and 1964 – 65 seasons.
 - 
  
  Jackie Robinson
 - 
  
  Bill Russell
 - 
  
  At this time the NBA took the ABA’s 4 most successful franchises: the Denver Nuggets, Indiana Pacers, San Antonio Spurs and the New York Nets (which would later become the New Jersey Nets, and then the Brooklyn Nets).
 - 
  
  Val James, for the Buffalo Sabres
 - 
  
  Johnny Grier
 - 
  
  Gavin Wanganeen, for the Essendon Football Club
 - 
  
  Charlie Williams, Game 4
 - 
  
  
 - 
  
  Robert Johnson, Charlotte Bobcats
 - 
  
  Mike Carey