Unknown 4

Should PED user's of the Steroid Era be Eligible for Hall of Fame Consideration?

  • National Baseball Hall of Fame

    National Baseball Hall of Fame
    • Player needs a 75% vote from baseball writers to be inducted
    • 317 members, 7 currently suspected of performance enhancing drug use
    • 5 year grace period
  • Period: to

    The Steroid Era

    No exact dates
    - A time of increased offensive production from PED use
    - Ended around 2003 with the implementation of league wide PED testing
  • Barry Bonds

    Barry Bonds
    (1986-2007)
    - 14 time all star
    - All time leader in Home runs (762)
    - OBP .444
    - Failed many PED tests
  • Roger Clemons

    Roger Clemons
    (1984-2007)
    - Pitcher
    - 7 time CY Young award winner
    - 11 time all-star
    - 354 credited wins
    - 3.12 career ERA
    - Third most strikeouts of all time
    Known steroid user
  • Juan Gonzalez gone from HOF ballots

    Juan Gonzalez gone from HOF ballots
    Jim Reeves - Former Player
    - A voter for the Hall of Fame
    - PEDs were a death Knell
    -Integrity and Character for Hall of Fame
    http://www.espn.com/dallas/mlb/story/_/id/7446551/specter-steroids-doomed-juan-gonzalez-hall-fame-hopes
  • Hall of Fame Voters Confront the Steroid Era and Its Questions By: Tyler Kepner

    Hall of Fame Voters Confront the Steroid Era and Its Questions By: Tyler Kepner
    Neutral Source
    - Discussed both sides of the argument
    - didn't choose a side, rather gave us a few examples from both sides
    - “there are no right answers.”
    http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/28/sports/baseball/steroid-era-players-pose-difficulty-for-hall-of-fame-voters.html
  • Cheating in Sports: A Moving Target

    Cheating in Sports: A Moving Target
    Against Performance Enchancing Drugs (PEDs)
    users being inducted into Hall of Fame Jose Antonio Tijerno - Hispanic Heritage Foundation
    - Domino Effect on next generation
    - Children take what they learn from sports and apply it to different areas of life
    - These players lack integrity and character
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jose-antonio-tijerino/cheating-in-sports-a-movi_b_2468088.html
  • Why I'm abstaining from HOF voting By: Buster Olney

    Why I'm abstaining from HOF voting By: Buster Olney
    Pro PED Users in Hall of Fame
    - One of the most prominent baseball writers of this topic
    - Hall of Fame is a shrine of baseball’s history
    - Mike Mussina
    - “is his career worthy of the Hall of Fame?”
    - No hall of Fame ballot
    http://insider.espn.com/blog/buster-olney/insider/post?id=8805
  • MLB Hall of Fame 2015: Time to open the doors to Steroids Era stars Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens By: Steve Politi

    MLB Hall of Fame 2015: Time to open the doors to Steroids Era stars Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens By: Steve Politi
    Pro PED Users in Hall of Fame
    - Barry Bonds
    - Roger Clemons
    - No Proof
    - Judgements based on no facts
    - the stats of some players are so much better than Hall of Famers
    -Museum of baseball history
    http://www.nj.com/yankees/index.ssf/2015/01/mlb_hall_of_fame_2015_time_of_open_the_doors_to_these_two_steroids_era_stars_politi.html
  • 2017 Hall of Fame Election Election

    2017 Hall of Fame Election Election
    Jeff Bagwell and Ivan Rodriguez join Ryne Sandberg, Cal Ripken, Paul Molitor, Mike Piazza, and Tony Gwynn as the only players elected to the Hall of Fame with suspicion of PED use.