Loss of self-control

Provocation

Period: Jun 1, 1949 to Oct 1, 2010

Duffy (1949)

Jun 27, 1949

Said loss of self-control must be sudden.

Bedder v DPP (1954)

Jun 27, 1954

He was impotent. He hired a prostitute, but could not have sex with her. So she teased him about his issue. He then strangled her. His impotency was not a characteristic that could be taken into account for a reasonable person.

Camplin v DPP (1979)

Jun 27, 1979

Camplin was a 15-yr-old boy. The victim drugged and raped him. He then teased Camplin about the fact that he had raped him. Camplin became angry, picked up a chapati pan and whacked him over the head twice, killing him.
The courts said that age and sex could be characteristics taken into account for the reasonable person.